Average rent in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan
Scroll for high-end rents and listing counts →
| Beds | Budget (10th) | Median | High-end (90th) | Listings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $2,600 | $3,800 | $4,396 | 119 |
| 1 Bedroom | $2,995 | $4,500 | $5,500 | 209 |
| 2 Bedrooms | $3,624 | $5,700 | $8,997 | 126 |
| 3 Bedrooms | $5,150 | $6,700 | $16,050 | 70 |
| 4 Bedrooms | $8,350 | $30,000 | $45,050 | 10 |
Apartments for rent in Carnegie Hill
The newest listings in Carnegie Hill from StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others. Each one opens on the site that posted it.
Features reported in listings
- Elevator
- Laundry in building
- Dishwasher
- Doorman
- Building gym
- Air conditioning
- Private outdoor space
- In-unit laundry
- Listings indicating some pets are allowed
Reported apartment size
- studio
- 1 bedroom
- 2 bedroom
Nearby subway routes
An MTA station is within 500 meters in a straight line of 528 of 531 geocoded listings. These are the most commonly nearby weekday routes, based on each listing’s nearest station. Straight-line distance does not measure walking access.
- 6 route
- 4 route
- 5 route
- 2 route
- 3 route
Weekday route data retrieved from the MTA Subway Stations dataset on October 28, 2026.
DHCR-listed buildings with tracked listings
22 indexable building pages have a listing address matched to the DHCR building registry. A building match does not confirm the status of any apartment in it.
- 175 East 96th Street
- 1510 Lexington Avenue
- 1501 Lexington Avenue
- 188 East 93rd Street
- 130 East 93rd Street
Showing the 5 linked buildings with the most listing history.
Based on Buzzedin listings tracked during the last 6 months. Feature shares count explicit affirmative reports over all tracked listings; a missing detail is unknown, not a negative. Apartment size is based on listings that report square footage. Updated October 28, 2026.
Carnegie Hill’s housing streets include several generations of residential buildings rather than one uniform apartment type. The Landmarks Preservation Commission’s designation report documents rows of late nineteenth-century houses, later freestanding townhouses and mansions, flats buildings, apartment hotels, and apartment buildings from the early twentieth century. These forms are concentrated within designated historic areas and along different street types; the report does not mean that every home in the larger neighborhood has a landmark designation.
For an apartment search, use the cross street and building form as starting points, then inspect the actual unit. A rowhouse or converted townhouse can differ from an apartment building in entrance, stairs, services, and room arrangement. Larger buildings may have elevators and shared facilities, but confirm those details with the listing contact. Request a floor plan with dimensions and windows marked. Check floor level, light from each room, closet and radiator placement, kitchen and bath condition, laundry, package handling, and any building access rules. Ask what utilities and appliances are included in writing.
The historic district is a defined set of properties, and the expanded district reaches beyond it. If a listing describes an address as landmarked or within a historic district, confirm it with the Landmarks Preservation Commission’s map. Historic designation can affect exterior changes and help explain a building’s facade, but it does not verify interior renovations, maintenance, or current building services. If original features matter to you, inspect their actual condition rather than relying on a general listing description.
Along a single route, a quieter side street and a wider avenue can present different storefront activity and building setbacks. Walk from the exact entrance to the places you expect to visit and check the immediate block. Keep notes by address so you do not confuse a district-wide architectural description with the particular apartment. The LPC report is valuable for understanding Carnegie Hill’s built history; a unit visit, precise floor plan, and written lease terms are what answer practical questions about a home.
Sources: NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission, Carnegie Hill Historic District report, NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission, Manhattan historic district maps, NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission, landmark map guidance
A one-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill is 10% below the Manhattan median for that apartment type.
Common questions
- What residential building types appear in Carnegie Hill?
- The Landmarks Preservation Commission report describes rowhouses, townhouses, mansions, flats buildings, apartment hotels, and later apartment buildings within the historic district. The larger neighborhood extends beyond those designated boundaries, so verify the specific address.
- Does historic-district status tell me whether an apartment has been renovated?
- No. The designation describes and regulates exterior historic features; it does not establish the current interior condition or building services. Inspect the unit and confirm any claimed upgrades directly.
- Which apartment features are reported in Carnegie Hill?
- Across Carnegie Hill's 532 tracked listings, the most commonly reported features are: Elevator was reported in 384 of 532 tracked listings (72%). Laundry in building was reported in 365 of 532 tracked listings (69%). Dishwasher was reported in 345 of 532 tracked listings (65%). These counts include explicit affirmative reports; listings without a mention are unknown, not negative.
- Which subway routes are near listings in Carnegie Hill?
- The nearest MTA station is within 500 meters in a straight line of 528 of 531 geocoded listings. The most commonly nearby weekday routes are 6, 4, 5, 2, 3. This is geographic proximity, not a walking-access or current-service guarantee. Source: MTA Subway Stations dataset.
- What is the median rent for a studio apartment in Carnegie Hill?
- The median asking rent for a studio apartment in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan is $3,800 per month, based on 119 listings from public rental listings Buzzedin tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others over the last 6 months. Updated October 2026. That matches the Manhattan median for the same apartment size.
- What is the median rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill?
- The median asking rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan is $4,500 per month, based on 209 listings from public rental listings Buzzedin tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others over the last 6 months. Updated October 2026. That is 10% below the Manhattan median of $4,975 for the same apartment size.
- What is the median rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill?
- The median asking rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan is $5,700 per month, based on 126 listings from public rental listings Buzzedin tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others over the last 6 months. Updated October 2026. That is 5% below the Manhattan median of $5,995 for the same apartment size.
- What is the median rent for a three-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill?
- The median asking rent for a three-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan is $6,700 per month, based on 70 listings from public rental listings Buzzedin tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others over the last 6 months. Updated October 2026. That is 13% below the Manhattan median of $7,727 for the same apartment size.
- What is the median rent for a four-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill?
- The median asking rent for a four-bedroom apartment in Carnegie Hill, Manhattan is $30,000 per month, based on 10 listings from public rental listings Buzzedin tracks on StreetEasy, NYBits, LeaseBreak and others over the last 6 months. Updated October 2026. That is 200% above the Manhattan median of $9,995 for the same apartment size.
- How do I find apartments in Carnegie Hill?
- Set up a Buzzedin alert for Carnegie Hill with your budget. We monitor new listings across major platforms and notify you within minutes when a matching apartment is posted.
Get alerts for Carnegie Hill.
Prices move fast in Carnegie Hill. Get notified within minutes when a new listing matches your budget.
Create a free alert